Research article

How has F&B supply affected the tenant mix?

The location drivers for different QSR, café and casual dining brands, varies from retail parks, to high streets, to shopping centres.


Several aspects of the F&B market have transformed rapidly since the end of the last decade, but high streets, shopping centres and retail parks have followed different courses.

Across the three subsectors analysed, the Top 5 brand stalwarts continue to dominate national provision. At location level, almost all growth since 2020 has come from the expansion of café and QSR formats in out-of-town retail locations. Casual dining brands that had significant retail park presence last decade have largely not been replaced like-for-like. Instead, provision has shifted towards convenience-led formats, playing directly to retail park strengths as efficient, accessible destinations. Drive-thru expansion has been instrumental to this.

Over the same period, high streets have recorded a net reduction in Top 5 brands, reflecting consolidation and changes in brand strategy. Shopping centres, by contrast, have seen little change, largely because established café and QSR operators have been seen as dependable tenants with strong consumer followings. Standalone leisure schemes were also analysed, but to simplify the narrative have not been isolated here because the statistics broadly mirror those of shopping centres.

Brands ranked 6-20 represent the disruptors. Although café and QSR operators in this group are beginning to gain traction on retail parks, their growth has been dwarfed by high street expansion. They have opened twice as many high street sites as shopping centres and retail parks combined.

The up-and-coming brands within the Top 50 have driven the greatest change in shopping centres, which have diversified their café and QSR offer through this cohort over the past six years. High street unit numbers are broadly unchanged from 2020, although the brand names have evolved. Some landlords have become more flexible on covenant, but operators typically still need an established track record before being accommodated.

For smaller brands ranked 50-100 moving from independent to small-chain status, the high street remains the melting pot. These are the ones to watch, with much of the market’s next phase of expansion likely to come from this group. Casual dining remains a shadow of its former scale, despite an increasingly promising pipeline of new brands. Growth is concentrated among these emerging operators, suggesting that the sector may have rebooted, with positive movement likely as lower-ranked brands expand.

Disruptor brands have opened twice as many high street sites as in shopping centres and retail parks combined

Food & beverage becomes a footfall driver

Even accounting for the ebb and flow of different subsectors, F&B has become an increasingly important part of the makeup of all retail place types over the last decade. For high streets, F&B typically accounts for 25-30% of the offer, while in shopping centres the proportions are 14-23%, with larger destinations having a more significant skew. The proportion of F&B units has increased by over 20% in the largest shopping centre destinations, but 17% for the market as a whole. This analysis is for units rather than floorspace. Larger destinations will have a more significant area devoted to F&B due to larger sized average retail units.

Retail parks have seen the biggest swing in provision, albeit from a lower base. F&B units now account for around a third more units than they did before Covid (the floorspace figure closer to 3%).

There are three primary reasons for these increases:

  • organic (natural evolution of occupational demand)
  • strategic (landlords proactively seeking to address changes in consumer demand)
  • reactive (as a last resort when no alternative retail tenant can be found)

The benefit is clear, F&B drives both footfall and dwell time. The key consideration is how much F&B is too much, and is it always the answer to a retail problem?  The risk of saturation is a real one. The amount of consumer spend remains finite, even as we spend a higher proportion of disposable income on leisure activities

Image treatment

Optimising the offer

The right F&B mix is strongly related to the type of retail place, with visit purpose, dwell and convenience all skewing the offer. F&B has often been seen as the sticking plaster for challenged spaces, but what mix is right for what place, and when is enough, enough?

Super regional malls broadly have an even weighting of café, QSR and full-service dining propositions, with each major scheme having an average of 38 outlets.  When considered on a floorspace basis, the casual dining offer is the most significant offer, though on average there are around 12 units provided within each F&B category. This includes a blend of the Top 5 operators that have probably been in place for a long period, as well as a mix of alternatives from the Top 100. Analysed at this granular level, there is a more significant number of lower ranking brands, indicating that variety and brand agility are important for the biggest retail schemes.

Similarly for prime city centre shopping centres, although the overall offer is around half of that in the super regionals - around 20 outlets - there is broad parity between the formats. For city centre schemes, brands outside of the Top 5 have started to become more important than those in it, especially when it comes to casual dining formats.

In Sub-regional and Community shopping centres, the significance of dining diminishes, and the role of quick and convenient formats dominates. The UK’s Top 5 operators account for around 75% of brands and cafés replace QSR as the most popular format. The balance in these smaller or secondary schemes, is retaining relevance and a point of difference, without over exposure to unproven formats.

 

Read the articles within Spotlight: Food and Beverage Property Insights - Market & location drivers of growth edition below.

Other articles within this publication

4 other article(s) in this publication