On 17 November 2020, the High Court dismissed an attempt by a campaign group to overturn the Government’s Permitted Development Rights and changes to the Use Class Order introduced in Summer 2020, meaning they currently remain in force. However, RCA have voiced their intent to appeal the High Court Judgement, and re-iterate on their website that they are appealing the decision. At the time of this update (January 2021), there is no indication that an appeal has been accepted by the courts. Savills will continue to monitor the situation.
The High Court has dismissed an attempt by a campaign group to overturn the Government’s recently introduced Permitted Development Rights and changes to the Use Class Order, meaning they currently remain in force.
The changes to the permitted development rights relate to those that allow for the upwards extension or demolition of certain buildings to provide additional flats. The changes to the Use Class Order have seen a simplification of the legislation establishing a new, single classification for ‘Commercial, Business and Service’ uses (Class E). The new Class E provides greater flexibility for commercial premises as changing between operations within the same use class (e.g. retail to restaurant) is not development as defined and as such does not require planning permission.
The legal challenge was brought by the Campaign group Rights: Community: Action (RCA), who asked the court to overturn the three statutory instruments that introduced the new permitted development rights and use class changes.
The RCA argued that the Statutory Instruments were brought in at pace without lawful due consideration of all the potential negative consequences – being environmental consequences, equality consequences, and harmful social consequences.
However, the High Court judgement rules that the Government did not fail to have regard to the public sector equality duty, and that the Statutory Instruments were not subject to a requirement for environmental assessment. The Court found no error on the Government’s behalf in bringing forward the proposals without additional consultation – noting that the speed in which they were introduced was proportionate given the economic emergency created by the coronavirus pandemic.
So, for now at least, these new permitted development rights and Use Class changes remain in force. However, Savills will continue to monitor the situation, as the RCA have voiced their intent to appeal the High Court Judgement.